Ready to eat healthy and live well?

Sign up for FREE recipes and goodies from me!

How to Make Homemade Nutella (dairy-free, vegan, paleo)

Posted by on September 14, 2016 / 14 Comments

Homemade nutella is easy to make and uses high-quality ingredients such as raw hazelnuts, cacao powder and unrefined coconut sugar.

(dairy-free, vegan, paleo) How to make homemade nutella. A delicious, healthier alternative with a step-by-step tutorial video.

Five videos are now done (in just a little over a month), can you believe it? Well, you guys are too nice so of course you’d never say no, but I fully admit to being a little shocked. I’d been dreaming of doing videos for the last year but just couldn’t quite pull the trigger. Between overseas travel, blog stuff, lots of technology excuses and well, nerves, they always got pushed toward the bottom of my list. But now, look, I’m a full-fledged YouTuber (and not a one-hit wonder!).

It makes so much sense to incorporate video, especially into a website that’s all about healthy food and cooking. In fact, for many of you, cooking and becoming comfortable in your kitchen may be an entirely new endeavor. So I’m hopefully that these little videos of mine nudge you to try something that you may not have tried before. Case in point…homemade nutella.

Watch the video and learn how to make homemade nutella:


As I was filming this “healthy basic” video I actually debated (for probably far too long) if I should say “healthy basic” as I usually do at the beginning of the video. I guess I felt a little guilty saying “nutella” and “healthy” in the same sentence. I mean, it’s a chocolate spread! But the honest truth is that while this is clearly not the healthiest of the “healthy basics” videos I’ve made, it’s still far healthier than the version you’ll buy at the store, where the first ingredient is sugar and includes dairy and soy.

This version on the other hand starts with toasted hazelnuts (which make your house smell amazing) and includes raw cacao powder which is known for it’s potent antioxidant benefits. Sure, it’s still sweetened with coconut sugar, but I include far less than the commercial counterpart. And that my friends right there is why you should “home-make” everything…you’re in control.

One quick note about this homemade nutella recipe. Many times you can replace maple syrup or honey for coconut sugar, but you can’t in this recipe. I tried it and it made the whole thing seize up, to no longer be beautifully spreadable. I even tried re-thinning it with oil and water, but it never returned to the perfect consistency of this version. So stick with coconut sugar or an organic powdered sugar.

And if you’re wondering, what should I put this on? Three words. Cassava flour crepes (oh, you know I’ll be doing a video on those soon as well).


(dairy-free, vegan, paleo) How to make homemade nutella. A delicious, healthier alternative with a step-by-step tutorial video.

How to Make Homemade Nutella (dairy-free, vegan, paleo)
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Homemade nutella is easy to make and uses high-quality ingredients. I think you'll love this healthy, homemade nutella recipe.
Serves: 1.5 cups
  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees fahrenheit.
  2. Place the hazelnuts on a sheet pan and spread them out. Cook for 10-12 minutes, or until the skins become dark and cracked.
  3. Let the hazelnuts cool to the touch, then transfer them to a kitchen towel and rub them until the majority of the skins have been removed.
  4. Place the hazelnuts into a food processor and blend for 5-6 minutes, or until you have a creamy hazelnut butter. Add the oil and blend for another minute.
  5. Add the sugar, cacao and vanilla and blend until fully combined. If you can powder the coconut sugar in a spice grinder before combining, even better.
  6. Pour the nutella into a storage container (where it will firm up slightly as it cools) or enjoy immediately.

Don’t forget to subscribe to my YouTube channel for more healthy cooking videos!

  • Kristina @ MsModify

    Can you believe I tried Nutella for the first time just a couple months ago?! Clearly I was living under a rock! I love that this is a healthier option with real ingredients!

    • If you live in the US, I’d say that’s totally understandable as it’s just not the “thing” it is in Europe. But it’s probably for the better, because now you can jump off on the healthier nutella foot! ;) x

  • Liz Stark

    Nourishing Nutella version + another awesome demo video = you’re on a roll! :) Love it. And I look forward to your upcoming crepe video!

  • francesca schroer

    Hi Lisa. This video was great! I was intimidatedthat to try the whole hazelnut roasting. .. but you made it look so easy. Thanks! I wanted to ask you, have you ever made this recipe with stevia? I’m having a hard time getting past the coconut sugar.
    When I first ran into your blog, the first thing that caught my eye was your raw cheesecake! I would love to see you make one. ..sometime!

    • Hi Francesca – So glad you’re loving the videos! I do have my raw cheesecake on the video “to do” list, though it may take a few months as the list is ever expanding. Lol. As for the nutella, I’ve not made it with stevia, but I think that should work fine. I think it’s the stickiness of the maple and honey that just don’t work as well in this recipe. Give it a try and let me know! And so glad you’re gonna give roasted hazelnuts a try. The smell and flavor is amazing and well worth the little bit of effort. :) x

  • Pingback: How to Make Chia Seed Jam - Downshiftology()

  • Pingback: How to Make Coconut Whipped Cream (dairy-free, paleo, vegan) - Downshiftology()

  • Pingback: How to Make Chia Seed Pudding (vegan, paleo) | Downshiftology()

  • Unknown

    How long can you store it?

    • You can store the homemade nutella for 1-2 months in the refrigerator. If you’d like to store longer, I’d recommend freezing it. Though to be honest, it never usually last that long in my house. ;)

  • Ruth J

    Can this be done in a Vitamix?

  • Pingback: How to Make Powdered Sugar (in 30 Seconds) | Downshiftology()

As Featured In

Ready to eat healthy and live well?

Sign up for FREE recipes and goodies from me!

© 2014 Downshiftology. All rights reserved.
Simple Share Buttons