Sweet Potato Casserole
121 Comments
Updated Nov 14, 2024
This post may contain affiliate links. See my disclosure policy.
This sweet potato casserole is a must-make Thanksgiving side dish. Fluffy and whipped spiced sweet potatoes are topped with the most delicious nutty pecan crumble. It’s packed with so much flavor and texture that you certainly won’t miss any marshmallow topping!
The Best Sweet Potato Casserole You’ll Have
Whenever Thanksgiving peeks around the corner, all the sweet potato recipes come to mind — mashed sweet potato, roasted sweet potatoes, spiced candied yams, and especially a sweet potato casserole. I’ve never been a huge fan of the traditional marshmallow-topped casserole (that’s overly sweet), so I always opt for this version that’s naturally sweetened with dates, vanilla, and cinnamon (that’s perfectly sweet). Here’s why I think you’ll love it too!
- It’s got a unique crumble topping. While most pecan toppings stick to just flour, pecans, and sugar, my version goes a step further with crunchy pepita seeds, chewy sweet dates, and almond flour. Bonus — it’s gluten-free and refined-sugar-free!
- It’s a Thanksgiving side dish everyone loves. Between the silky sweet potatoes and crunchy nutty texture, this dish is always one of the first ones to disappear. If you’re not sure what to bring, this classic Thanksgiving recipe is a no-brainer.
- You can make it ahead of time. Simply make the sweet potato base and nutty topping the day before, then combine and bake right before serving. I’ve got more tips on that below!
Sweet Potato Casserole Ingredients
- Sweet Potatoes: Instead of baking, I boil my sweet potatoes to create a silky, creamy texture. This will also save you some time!
- Milk: You can use any type of milk, whether that’s dairy or dairy-free. I often use my homemade cashew milk as it’s got a creamy and nutty flavor that mixes well with the sweet potatoes.
- Butter: Melted butter adds extra creaminess to the sweet potatoes. If you or your guests are dairy-sensitive, you can swap in ghee or vegan butter.
- Spices: A bit of cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, pepper, and vanilla extract bring a spicy-sweet aroma to the sweet potato layer.
- Pecan Crumble Topping: This is a blend of chopped pecans, dates, pepitas, and almond flour. It’s naturally sweetened from the dates, while the pecans and pepitas give it a savory crunch.
Find the printable recipe with measurements below.
Ingredient Substitutions
- Dairy-free option → Swap the butter for ghee or vegan butter, and swap the milk for dairy-free milk.
- Nut-free option → Swap the pecans with oats.
- Swap the nuts and seeds → Walnuts, chopped pistachios, pumpkin seeds, or pine nuts would be delicious options.
- Swap the dates → Other dried fruits such as dried cranberries, raisins, or dried apricots would work well.
How To Make This Sweet Potato Casserole
Boil the sweet potatoes. Bring a large pot of water to boil, peel and dice the sweet potatoes, and then cook them for 20 to 30 minutes, until fork tender.
Make the sweet potato layer. Drain the sweet potatoes in a colander and mash them in a large bowl with a hand masher or electric hand mixer (I prefer the latter for the fluffiest texture). Then, add the butter and milk into the bowl and mix until it’s perfectly creamy.
Make the crumble topping. Roughly chop the pecans, dates, and pepitas and toss them in a large bowl. Then, add the almond flour and butter and mix with your hands until everything is combined.
Assemble the casserole. Spread the sweet potato in a flat layer in a 9×13-inch baking dish. Sprinkle the pecan crumble on top in an even layer.
Baking time! Bake for 25 to 30 minutes at 375°F (190°C), until the top becomes lightly golden brown. Remove it from the oven, then serve it up!
Prepare This Casserole Ahead Of Time
On Thanksgiving, time-saving tips are our savior! So here’s how you can meal prep this sweet potato casserole ahead of time.
- Make the components the day before. After you’ve made both the bottom sweet potato layer and the topping, store them separately in airtight containers in the fridge.
- Bake on Thanksgiving. The next day, take the mixtures out of the fridge and let the sweet potatoes come to room temperature for about 30 minutes. Then, assemble the casserole and bake for 20 to 30 minutes or until the top is beautifully golden. So easy!
More Thanksgiving Side Dishes
- Cranberry Sauce: This homemade version is undoubtedly the best.
- Creamed Corn: Add a vibrant yellow dish of corn to your holiday table.
- Classic Mashed Potatoes: This is a classic for a reason!
- Peas and Pancetta: I simply call this my famous Thanksgiving peas.
- Parmesan Herb Roasted Acorn Squash: A deliciously savory take on acorn squash.
- Balsamic Bacon Brussels Sprouts: My all-time favorite side dish.
- Roasted Butternut Squash Soup: The perfect seasonal soup.
- Or browse through my list of Thanksgiving recipes or sweet potato recipes for more delicious ideas!
I hope everyone at your Thanksgiving dinner enjoys this sweet potato casserole! If you make it, I’d love to hear how this turned out in the comment box below. Your review will help other readers in the community. And if you’re hungry for more healthy food inspiration (and exclusive content), join my free newsletter.
Sweet Potato Casserole
Description
Video
Equipment
- Casserole Pan Here's a great set of pans if you need it!
Ingredients
Sweet Potatoes
- 3 large (about 3 pounds) sweet potatoes, peeled and cut into chunks
- ¼ cup milk
- ¼ cup butter, melted
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon cinnamon
- ½ teaspoon nutmeg
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt
- ¼ teaspoon ground black pepper
Topping
- ¾ cup pecans, roughly chopped
- ¼ cup pepitas, roughly chopped
- 4 Medjool dates, pitted and roughly chopped
- ¼ cup almond flour
- 2 tablespoons butter, melted
Instructions
- Boil the sweet potatoes. Bring a large pot of water to rolling boil over high heat. Place the sweet potato chunks into the pot and cook for 20 to 30 minutes, or until fork tender.
- Blend the sweet potatoes. Drain the potatoes, then place them in a large mixing bowl. Mash them with a hand masher or electric beater.
- Mix sweet potato layer. Add the milk, butter, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, and black pepper, and continue mixing until creamy.
- Make the pecan crumble. Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). In a mixing bowl, add the pecans, pepitas, dates, almond flour, and butter. Mix thoroughly with your hands until combined.
- Assmble and bake. Spread the mashed sweet potato into an even layer in a 9 x 13-inch baking dish. Then sprinkle the crumble mixture on top. Bake for 25 to 30 minutes, or until the top is golden brown.
Lisa’s Tips
- Make-ahead tip: After making the mashed sweet potatoes and pecan crumble topping, store them separately and tightly covered in the fridge. The next day, take them out of the fridge and let the sweet potatoes come to room temperature for about 30 minutes. Then, assemble the casserole and bake for 20 to 30 minutes, or until the top is beautifully golden.
- Tweak the crumble topping by swapping the pecans or pepitas for other nuts and seeds such as walnuts, chopped pistachios, pumpkin seeds, or pine nuts. You could also swap the dates for other dried fruit.
- If you can’t have almond flour, feel free to use the flour of your choice.
- To create a creamier sweet potato layer, use a food processor, hand mixer, or stand mixer to blend.
- To make it dairy-free, you can swap butter for ghee and use any type of dairy-free milk.
Nutrition
©Downshiftology. Content and photographs are copyright protected. Sharing of this recipe is both encouraged and appreciated. Copying and/or pasting full recipes to any social media is strictly prohibited.
Recipe originally posted November 2019, but updated to include new photos and a video for your benefit!
Made this for Thanksgiving this year, and it was a hit! Since we have a bunch of Downshiftology recipes that have become staples, I had every confidence in it despite never having made it before. I followed the recipe exactly, and it came out great!!
Hi MJ – thanks so much for trusting in my recipes! I’m thrilled you enjoyed this sweet potato casserole. Happy Thanksgiving!
I made this for Thanksgiving dinner today and it was absolutely delicious and a big hit! I love sweet potatoes and it was nice to have a more savory dish and not the sweet marshmallow dish. This will be on repeat. Already planning to make it for Christmas dinner too. Thank you, Lisa!!
Hi Dale – I’m happy to hear this recipe was such a hit that you’re making it again for Christmas, yay!
This recipe is phenomenal! Even my three-year-old eats it!! I love that it is more on the savory side and not overly sweet, and I serve it with maple syrup if you want a little drizzle of sweetness. I may toast the pepitas next go round. Definitely saving this for years to come!
So happy you and your little one love it! And yes, a splash of maple syrup is a great sweetener. Enjoy!
Can I freeze this all assembled including the nut topping ahead of time ? Thanks
Hi Lynne – I probably wouldn’t recommend freezing, as freezing can change the texture of veggies (even pureed ones) once they’re thawed. But you can certainly make it a day in advance and refrigerate it!
Hello! Very happy to see this healthy recipe vs the overly sweet other recipes out there. Great idea using the dates in the crumble. Thank you for sharing with such detailed instructions!
Hi Nicole – Of course! I believe this version is equally delicious. Hope you enjoy for Thanksgiving!
Sounds delicious! I’m going to make this for our potluck here in our Senior Residential Community.
Wonderful! I hope you all enjoy it, Cathleen!
Hi Lisa,
Do you serve this with savoury components please?
Hi Anne-Marie – Yes! This is the perfect side dish for your Thanksgiving spread, or with any savory main.
Hello Lisa,
I’m going to bring your sweet potato casserole to Thanksgiving dinner. The pepitas in your ingredient list didn’t state salted or unsalted. What is your preference? Also, how many people does this casserole serve?
Happy Thanksgiving to you!
Hi Judy – I use raw (unsalted) pepitas in this recipe. And it serves about 8 to 10 people. Enjoy and Happy Thanksgiving!
Easy to make, absolutely scrumptious.
Hi Piroska – Happy to hear you’re loving this sweet potato casserole!
Looks yummy. Can you make it in advance and can you freeze it?
Hi Eva – For the best texture and flavor, you can make the sweet potato later and crumble topping and store in the fridge for a day or two, then assemble and bake when you’re ready.
I just made your sweet potato casserole and it is so creamy and delicious. I love casseroles and sweet potatoes, what a great find. The pecans and pepitas made me love it even more. The fact that you made it healthy worked perfectly for me. My family loved it also, so this will be my contribution to our Thanksgiving celebration. Thank you so much for sharing your recipes.
Yay, I’m so thrilled that you loved this recipe, Laura! Happy Thanksgiving!
This sweet potato recipe is THE BEST! We used to make the traditional one with crumble and marshmallows…but it was just too rich alongside everything else. My whole family loves this lighter, yet delicious, version and have been making it for several years. It has all the flavors we want, but leaves room for the rest of the food.
Go, Lisa!!
Thanks so much, Jennifer! Yes, it’s a great option for a sweet potato casserole that’s not overly sweet, just perfectly sweet. ;) Happy you love it!
Can’t wait to make it for our Friendsgiving! Do you have an alternative to dates for the topping? A gal in our group can’t eat dates. Thanks!
Hi Courtney – you could use any dried fruit you prefer!
I made it at Thanksgiving and there was barely anything left for the next day. Making sweet potato casserole for Christmas too. Love it.
It really is great for so many holidays! Happy you love the recipe, Sara!
It hasn’t been Thanksgiving until I’ve had the sweet potato casserole – its my favorite staple. My recipe is old school and LOOOOOAAAADED with sugar and dairy and is wildly unhealthy. I made enough of Lisa’s recipes to trust her so I tried this one out on Thanksgiving. Massive hit. I loved it and so did everyone else (I caught people going back for 3rds… AFTER their meal!) You’d never guess there is no added sugar at all in this recipe.
Substitutions: I did tweak things slightly for our crowd since we had a couple vegetarians and a vegan. Swapped out the butter for equal portions of coconut oil, swapped out the milk for oat milk. I also doubled the topping & put it in a slightly smaller pan because I just love the crunchy topping.
Yay, I’m so thrilled you loved this sweet potato casserole recipe, Josh! Thanks for sharing your substitutions as well. :)
Loved this recipe!! I made it for my moms house and my in-laws house so we had a healthy option to eat and it was a huge hit. Both families loved it especially my mother in law. Surprisingly even my husband
Wonderful! So happy the entire family loved it. Thanks, Bia!
I am allergic to almonds. What is a better alternative for the almond flour?
Hi Megan – you can use any nut or seed flour. You can also grind up any other nuts or seeds you prefer to make flour at home.
This recipe was perfect! I have been looking for a sweet potato casserole that wasn’t too rich or sweet and this hit the spot. I haven’t come across a recipe here that I wasn’t impressed with. Thank you for creating a delicious dish that I will use years to come!
Thanks so much, Susie! I’m happy you loved this sweet potato casserole. And other recipes on my website as well. Happy Thanksgiving!
Great recipe! Your recipes are always spot on and thoughtful in execution! You’ve made me look like a rockstar cook! :) So for the sweet potato casserole, my family will become my enemies if I leave off the marshmallows. haha. Would you recommend just broil them on top in right before servicing? Thanks for your feedback!
Haha, guess you have to keep the family happy as well. ;) Yes, I’d just broil them on top before serving. Enjoy!
I have made the sweet potato casserole for the last 3 Thanksgiving dinners. It’s always appreciated because most of my family doesn’t like the traditional marshmallow sweet potato dish.
The dish is just sweet enough and it’s healthier for your body.
Yay, I’m happy you and your family love it! Thanks for coming back and making it year after year, Heidi!
Lisa, planning on making this as a Thanksgiving side dish ;-) Question: would you add crispy (fully rendered) bacon pieces to the topping to add a bit of a savory note, or would that mess up the dish?? Thanks!
I think that would taste amazing! Sweet and savory is a great combo. And there’s a reason why people love maple bacon. ;)
Just quick note, the measurements for the sweet potatoes does not change from (about 3 pounds) when you adjust to 1x, 2x or 3x serving size.
Hi Lisa! I have an abundance of garnet yams. Can I substitute them for the sweet potatoes? Maybe bake them instead of boiling. I love the idea with the crumble! Thank you!
Hi Janice – yes, those should work just fine! Hope you enjoy the casserole. :)
I made this last year and it was a amazing! It’s our new go to that is actually healthier!
Can this be made ahead except for the topping and frozen for travelling?
Yes, it sure can! Hope you enjoy it again this year Jennifer!
Like to try this recipe this year for Thanksgiving. Can I make the night before and add toppings before I put in the oven on Thanksgiving.
Yes, you sure can!
Looks amazing. Is it ok to use avocado oil in place of the better/ghee for the sweet potatoes? Also what can I use for the topping instead of butter/ghee? You mention nut milk subbing for these, but I would imagine that will not work for the topping? Would the same avocado oil work? Many thanks.
Hi! An- I am gluten and dairy free of necessity. I use unrefined coconut oil for the potatoes and topping. Works perfectly! And all my family and friends LOVE this dish even though they are not gf nor df. It’s always asked for past 3 years.
Will substituting ghee and almond milk eliminate or lower the 24 mg of cholesterol? I’m trying to be very careful. It sounds great! I’m excited to try this healthier version for Thanksgiving. Thanks!
This was a hit during our 2020 thanksgiving dinner. Even with my husband that is not a big fan of sweet potatoes. I also follow an AIP diet and this recipe was super easy to modify!
Amazing! So glad this casserole was a hit :)
I wanted a few healthier versions to choose from for Thanksgiving dinner my husband and I made this together. It was fun to cook something as a team and it turned out absolutely delicious. It was a little daunting dicing up the sticky dates so when I make this again I will probably buy them already packaged. Lol
But the point is I will definitely be making it again it was very tasty and such a healthier version of a famous holiday dish. Lisa never disappoints
So glad you enjoyed this healthier version :)
This was hands down my favorite Thanksgiving dish! It is so good! Thanks for the fantastic recipe, Lisa!
Wonderful! Glad you loved this recipe Belinda :)
YUM! So versatile and delicious, as are all of your recipes. I had walnuts, so I used those. This was a hit with the family, and I’ll surely be making it again. Thank you!
Wonderful! Glad to hear this was loved by everyone over the holidays.
Can I make this with a white sweet potato or does it have to be the yellow one ?
You can use any color you’d like.
Hi, thank you for this recipe. I wonder if I can use brown sugar or raisins in place of the dates, and oat flour OR all purpose flour for the almond flour? Also, sunflower seeds for the pepitas? I’m not on a strict diet, or any diet for that matter, so I think having nuts and seeds instead of the usual sweet potato/marshmallow recipe is already a great healthy change. I’m sorry to butcher this great sounding recipe but I don’t have these ingredients and prefer to use what I already have. Thank you so much again.
Hi Micayla – all of those substitutions sound like they’d work. I hope you enjoy it!
Hi Lisa, Can this be made ahead of time? I have some sweet potatoes now, and would love to freeze this casserole for Thanksgiving. Would you recommend that for this recipe? Thanks!
Hi Liz- Yes it can! I actually have instructions for this written in the blog post :)
Hi Lisa! I am looking forward to trying this recipe for Thanksgiving this year. My husband is allergic to nuts — do you have a suggestion for substituting the pecans?
Thanks!
Jessica
Hi Jessica – how about oats? I think that would make a great combo with the seeds as well. :)
My cousin is newly vegan and I’m on a low carb diet and for Christmas I wanted to make a side we could count on if nothing else followed our food guidelines. This won everyone in my family’s heart and people could not believe how delicious this was. Thank you for your easy to follow recipes that are packed with flavor!
Hi Samantha – So glad to hear this was a hit over Thanksgiving!
Loved everything about this recipe, from how easy to make it was to how delicious it is. Thank you!
Of course Raquel! So glad you love this sweet potato casserole :)
I made this for Thanksgiving, it was a big hit because it was so delicious!
Hi Lisa – Amazing! Glad to hear this was a success over Thanksgiving :)
I served this for Thanksgiving and it was a definite hit with our family. So much healthier than previous sweet potato casseroles I’ve served for the holidays. Very easy and fast to make plus the nut topping is perfect! This recipe has become a staple to our holiday meals moving forward! Thanks!
I’m so happy you loved this casserole recipe Athena! I agree that it’s still packed with flavor and even though it’s healthy, it’s just as satisfying as the more traditional version.:)
Made this for Thanksgiving, it was a hit! This is going in the rotation from now on.
Hi Diane – Amazing! Glad to hear you’ll be making this recipe again next year :)
Made this for Thanksgiving so east and delicious. Loved the nut and seeds topping. I froze the leftovers I didn’t want it to go to waste.
Hi Cynthia – So glad you and your family enjoyed this recipe over Thanksgiving :)
Made this for thanksgiving and everybody loved. A lot of “wow who made this sweet potato casserole!!!” so simple and I felt good knowing what was in it!
Hi Whitney – A Thanksgiving success! Glad to hear everyone enjoyed this casserole :)
I made this recipe at Thanksgiving and it turned out perfectly! It was so simple and easy. My family was stunned when I explained that it was a healthy spin on sweet potato casserole because it honestly tastes way yummier than the naughty version with marshmallows. I’ll definitely be making this again next year!
Hi Mackenzie – It really does taste like the real thing huh :) It’s the perfect way to sneak in some healthiness to your Thanksgiving table!
I made this dish for a Rio de Janeiro Thanksgiving, using organic sweet potatoes, a mixed nut milk, ghee instead of butter, and finally walnuts (because I was also making a pecan pie). The result was an impressively smooth baked purée with a crunchy granola-like topping, which everybody raved about. I will be making this again, and also sharing the recipe. Thank you!
Wonderful! I’m so happy you loved the recipe Siri!
I made this for Thanksgiving dinner. It was loved by everyone and they appreciated that it was a healthy version of the casserole. I will be making this again and again. Thank you.
Hi Nan – I’m so happy you and your friends/family loved this recipe. Thanks for sharing! :)
I made this and it was a hit. I didn’t have the dates so I substituted organic sun dried calimyrna figs.
That’s a great sub with the figs! You could use almost any dried fruit on the topping and it would taste fab. So happy you loved it!
Loveee how yummy and healthy this sounds! Thanks for sharing. :)
Thanks Kate! I hope you enjoy the recipe!
I’ll take my sweet potatoes any way I can get them, I’m obsessed ~ but if they’re healthy, all the better!
I’m right there with you Sue! And there’s so much flavor in this casserole recipe. Enjoy!
This sweet potato casserole looks amazing and I love that it’s healthy!
It’s so creamy and fluffy with the perfect crumble topping. I hope you enjoy the recipe Julia!
This was one of my favorite dishes to eat growing up. I like this healthier version. Will be giving it a try.
Wonderful! I hope you enjoy this lighter version Mirlene!
We love sweet potato casserole during the Holidays! I’m loving this healthy version!
Yes, it’s the best! And this healthy version is a great option during the holidays. So happy you love it Tisha!
Hi Lisa! Do you think if I subbed Japanese sweet potato it would still be good?
Hi Abi – yes, I think it would still be delicious with Japanese sweet potatoes. If anything, it might be a little sweeter. :)
Hi Lisa! Can I substitute butter with coconut oil?
Hi Sunny – Yes! You can do that :) Enjoy the recipe!
I happen to have some extra coconut milk, do you think that would be an ok substitute for regular milk?
Hi Jennifer – yes, you can use that in this recipe as well!